CIDR's Research & Analysis Plan
CIDR will begin with a highly collaborative design and development phase, working with district partners, educators, former multilingual learners, and experts across the United States and internationally to design and refine the professional learning model and its research tools. In addition to refining the model itself, this phase will support the development, piloting, and validation of study-specific measures—including classroom self-assessments and student measures—that are grounded in the CIDR framework and appropriate for participating students, educators, and local contexts. This process will ensure that CIDR is research-informed and remains responsive to the varied immigrant-, refugee-, and multilingual-background students, their teachers, and learning settings.
Following initial design, we will conduct a two-year design-based study with educators and students across rural, urban, and suburban North Carolina districts. Teachers will engage with the CIDR professional learning model and use emerging tools—including classroom self-assessments focused on openness, interconnectedness, agency, curiosity, and creativity—to reflect on practice, gather evidence from students, and adapt instruction. Students will participate in CIDR-informed learning experiences and contribute feedback, reflections, and artifacts that help us understand how classroom practices shape their learning, relationships, sense of belonging, agency, and critical reading. Across iterative cycles, we will examine the feasibility, usability, and promise of the professional learning model and modify it accordingly. These changes will be informed by how teachers interpret and enact CIDR; and how students experience changes in classroom learning, relationships, belonging, agency, and critical reading.
Our analysis will bring together surveys, classroom observations, lesson plans, student work, interviews, teacher reflections, and student-created multimodal artifacts. We may also draw on implementation records, professional learning attendance and engagement data, teacher inquiry logs, classroom interaction data, student attendance and mobility data, and relevant school-level contextual information. Findings from each implementation cycle will inform refinements to the professional learning model, classroom self-assessments, and study measures.
Following this two-year design-based phase, we will conduct a mixed-methods, quasi-experimental study to examine the effectiveness of the refined CIDR model. We will compare participating classrooms with similar classrooms that are not yet participating in CIDR, using baseline student, teacher, and school characteristics to create or identify appropriate comparison groups. Quantitative analyses will examine differences in student and teacher outcomes at the end of the school year while accounting for baseline scores and the nesting of students within classrooms and schools. We will also model growth from pre- to end-of-year, estimating whether students in CIDR classrooms demonstrate greater growth in literacy, language, wellbeing, belonging, and agency than comparable students in nonparticipating classrooms.
Qualitative analyses will help explain how and why observed patterns emerge. We will use critical discourse analysis of teacher interviews, reflective inquiry records, and selected classroom materials to examine how educators make sense of multilingualism, students’ identities and knowledge, power, and the possibilities of CIDR in practice. We will integrate qualitative and quantitative data to examine patterns and growth across coded observations, teacher reflections, lesson plans, and student work, identifying how key CIDR orientations and instructional practices co-occur and how those patterns change over time. Together, these analyses will connect evidence of implementation, classroom practice, and student experience to outcomes across varied local contexts.
Will take place in 3 NC districts in rural, urban, and suburban contexts
60+ educators and 600+ students will participate
Measurements
Student Measurements
-
Relational student wellbeing, belonging, and agency: student surveys
- Identity, sense of self, and voice: multimodal artifacts, student reflections, and interviews or focus groups
- Critical in-depth reading and academic literacy: document-based questions, student work, and performance-based tasks
- Classroom experience and instructional access: brief student feedback measures, classroom interaction data, and selected attendance or engagement indicators
Teacher measurements
- Instructional practice and implementation of CIDR: observations, lesson plans, student work, surveys, and classroom self-assessments
- Beliefs, knowledge, and confidence in supporting multilingual learners: surveys
- Experiences, adaptations, and perceptions of student change: interviews and reflective inquiry records
- Engagement with professional learning and use of CIDR tools: participation records, learning artifacts, and teacher inquiry logs